Background Check Advice
Background Check Issues
A mistake in your criminal history record can cost you a job or a license, or interfere with your travel. I contact law enforcement record holders to correct entries that are wrong. For clients struggling with what to say about their past, I also give confidential advice on how to answer background check forms truthfully and lawfully.
Background checks decide who gets hired, who gets licensed, and who gets cleared for federal work. Official recordkeepers can make mistakes, and criminal histories are sometimes wrong or incomplete. A dismissed case could show up as still open. Someone else's record could mistakenly land in your file. A warrant that was recalled years ago may still be listed as active.
For more than 20 years as an Assistant Federal Public Defender, I reviewed criminal histories all the time and investigated errors. I know how these record systems are built, where the errors come from, and which agency has to fix them.
I help with two things:
- Confidential advice before you sign. The SF-85P, other federal background forms, and official applications that ask about your past.
- Correcting inaccurate records. FBI criminal history records and state records.
Call or text 503-888-8076.
Confidential advice on background check forms
Federal jobs, federal contracts, and many official applications require a signed questionnaire about your past. The questions are harder than they look. They ask about arrests, charges, drug use, debts, and job history. Each question has its own wording and its own time period.
There are two ways to get hurt:
- Saying too little. A knowingly false answer or omission on a federal form is a felony. 18 U.S.C. § 1001. A false answer can also be its own reason to find you unsuitable for the job, even when the underlying event would not have been.
- Saying too much. People often volunteer information the question does not ask for, or describe an event inaccurately because they never saw the court record.
Often the answer causes more trouble than the event.
I do not help anyone hide the truth. I help you answer truthfully, completely, and precisely. That means:
- Reading each question against your actual record
- Pulling court and agency records so your answers match the paper
- Explaining what a question asks and what it does not, including how it treats dismissed, sealed, or set-aside cases
- Helping you write clear explanations where the form allows them
- Preparing you for the investigator's interview
- Advising you on how to correct a form you already submitted
Your conversations with me are confidential and protected by the attorney-client privilege. A recruiter, HR officer, or security officer cannot offer that. They work for the agency.
Errors in FBI and state criminal records
Police officers, federal agencies, and border officers rely on FBI databases. These include the National Crime Information Center (NCIC) and the FBI's criminal history file, often called a rap sheet or Identity History Summary. Common errors include:
- A case that was dismissed but still shows as open
- A missing final disposition
- A warrant that was recalled or served but never cleared
- A conviction that a court set aside but that still appears
- Another person's record mixed with yours
These errors do more than cost you a job. An uncleared warrant can turn a traffic stop into an arrest. A wrong entry can mean secondary screening at the airport or the border. It can also sink a fingerprint-based check for a license or a federal position.
The right tool depends on who holds the record:
- FBI records. You can request your own Identity History Summary and challenge entries that are wrong or incomplete. 28 C.F.R. §§ 16.30 to 16.34. The FBI corrects its file once the agency that submitted the entry confirms the correction.
- The source agency. The lasting fix is usually at the source: the court, the prosecutor, or the arresting agency. I go to the source with certified records and follow the correction through to the FBI.
- Oregon records. State criminal history is kept by the Oregon State Police and has its own review and challenge process.
- Travel screening. Repeated screening problems can be raised through the Department of Homeland Security's redress program, DHS TRIP.
- Other federal agency records. The Privacy Act requires agencies to keep the records they use to make decisions about you accurate, relevant, timely, and complete enough to be fair. 5 U.S.C. § 552a(e)(5). You can ask an agency to amend a record that falls short. Agencies may be exempt from some parts of the Act, but I have successfully gotten federal authorities to correct misleading criminal history entries.
You cannot look yourself up in NCIC. I can help you find out what the government's records say about you through the channels the law provides, then work to correct what is wrong.
The SF-85P: Questionnaire for Public Trust Positions
Standard Form 85P is the questionnaire for federal employees and contractors in public trust positions. These are jobs that do not require a security clearance but carry real responsibility, such as access to sensitive data, money, or systems.
The SF-85P is completed online. It asks about:
- Where you have lived, worked, and gone to school
- People who know you
- Military service
- Your police record
- Illegal drug use
- Your finances, including delinquent debts
- Prior background investigations
Some positions require an added supplement, the SF-85P-S.
When you sign, you certify that your answers are true and you authorize the government to check them. Investigators compare your answers to fingerprint-based FBI records, credit reports, court files, and employer records. Many positions are now subject to continuous vetting, so the government keeps checking after you are hired.
Marijuana deserves a special note in Oregon. It is legal under state law and illegal under federal law. Federal forms ask about federal law.
The form is changing. The government has begun replacing the SF-85, SF-85P, and SF-86 with a single form, the Personnel Vetting Questionnaire (PVQ). Your agency will tell you which form applies to you. The duty is the same on either one: complete and truthful answers.
Tiers of federal background investigations
The depth of the investigation depends on the risk and sensitivity of the position. The government has used five tiers and is consolidating them into three.
| Tier | Type of position | Form | New tier |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tier 1 | Low risk, non-sensitive. Also used for federal ID credentials. | SF-85 | Low |
| Tier 2 | Moderate-risk public trust | SF-85P | Moderate |
| Tier 3 | Non-critical sensitive. Secret clearance. | SF-86 | Moderate |
| Tier 4 | High-risk public trust | SF-85P | High |
| Tier 5 | Critical or special sensitive. Top Secret clearance. | SF-86 | High |
Higher tiers reach further back and look deeper. They can include interviews with you and with people who know you. An answer that goes unnoticed at a lower tier may be examined closely if you later move to a higher one.
Other applications I advise on
The same care applies to other applications that are signed under penalty of law:
- Trusted traveler programs such as Global Entry and TSA PreCheck
- Professional and occupational license applications
- Security clearance questionnaires (SF-86)
- Federal contracting and grant certifications
How it works
- Confidential consultation. You tell me what happened and what is at stake. I tell you whether I can help.
- Records first. I show you how to obtain your existing background records so we know where you stand.
- A written plan and a clear fee. You know the scope and the cost before you owe anything.
- The work. I pursue the correction, or go through your form with you question by question.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to report an arrest if the case was dismissed?
It depends on the exact wording of the question. Some questions ask only about convictions. Many ask about arrests or charges no matter how the case ended. Read the question, not the summary of it. I can go through it with you.
What if my record was expunged or set aside?
Do not assume you can leave it off. Federal forms often require you to report a case even if it was sealed, expunged, or set aside, with narrow exceptions written into the form. The answer turns on the form and the type of order.
Marijuana is legal in Oregon. Do I have to report it?
Federal forms ask about drugs that are illegal under federal law. State law does not change the question. How you answer, and how you explain it, matters.
I already submitted a form with a wrong answer. What now?
Get advice before you do anything else. A prompt, voluntary correction is usually far better than waiting for an investigator to find the problem. How you correct it matters.
How long does it take to fix an FBI or state record?
It depends on the agency that created the entry. The fix usually starts at the source, such as the court or the arresting agency, and then has to reach the FBI. That can take time, so it is best to start early.
Can you remove accurate information?
No. Accurate records generally stay. But a court order setting aside a conviction can change how the record should read, and I can make sure the record reflects it.
Is my consultation confidential?
Yes. What you tell me is confidential, whether or not you hire me.
Talk to me about background check issues that could get in the way of your future plans.
I will personally respond when you contact me.
Call or text 503-888-8076, or email tex@defenderclark.com. Please do not send confidential details by text or email.